Staff Writer
HARARE — Every morning before the sun crests the horizon, the streets of Harare transform into a sprawling engine of survival. From the stacks of second-hand clothes at Mbare to the makeshift vegetable stalls lining CBD pavements, the informal sector is the lifeblood of a nation where formal employment remains a luxury.
But this week, that engine began to sputter under the weight of an invisible clock.
Following a directive from Local Government and Public Works Minister Daniel Garwe, thousands of traders have been given until September 9 to vacate their “unauthorized” spots and move to designated markets. While the government frames this as a necessary step toward the “Clean City” goals of Vision 2030, a blistering petition from the representative body
“We the People – People’s Parliament” suggests the order is less a roadmap and more an “impossible mandate.”
The Math of Displacement
The core of the crisis lies in a simple, devastating calculation. According to the petition signed by Chairperson Thembakhuye Moyo and Secretary Tafadzwa Kutya, the city’s current infrastructure is a hollow shell. They allege that the Harare City Council lacks the capacity to house even 5% of the current informal workforce.
“You cannot move a forest into a flowerpot,” says one vendor, who asked to remain anonymous for fear of municipal reprisal. “They tell us to go to ‘designated spaces,’ but when we get there, there is nothing but dust and overcrowding. We aren’t here to break the law; we are here to feed our children.”
The petition, titled “We Have a Right to Belong to the City,” challenges the Ministry’s logic: if the designated stalls don’t exist, the order to move isn’t a relocation—it is an eviction into destitution.
The Policy Paradox
Analysis of the government’s stance reveals a curious contradiction in policy. Minister Garwe’s directive cites the National Development Strategy 2 (NDS2) and Vision 2030 as the impetus for the cleanup. These frameworks envision a middle-income society with world-class infrastructure.
However, the People’s Parliament points out that NDS2 also explicitly commits to the “formalization of the informal economy through inclusive growth.”
Herein lies the friction: Can you formalize an economy by dismantling it? By removing traders before building the “sheltered, serviced markets” they were promised, critics argue the government is putting the cart before the horse. Instead of bringing traders into the tax-paying fold, a forced crackdown risks pushing them further into the shadows, stripping them of the very dignity the “Decent Work” agenda seeks to provide.
Economic Fallout and The Human Cost
The timing of the ultimatum—just seven days—has been described by many as a “death sentence” for micro-enterprises. Unlike large corporations, informal traders operate on razor-thin margins and daily cash flows. A week of displacement doesn’t just mean a loss of profit; it means school fees go unpaid and tables go empty.
The petition warns of “absolute destitution.” For a city already grappling with high inflation and limited social safety nets, the prospect of thousands of breadwinners losing their livelihoods overnight poses a significant risk to social stability.
A Path Forward: Collaboration over Confrontation
The People’s Parliament is not calling for chaos or permanent street obstruction. In fact, their petition expresses an “eager” desire to be legalized, registered, and to pay municipal fees. Their demand is simple:
Time and Infrastructure
They are calling for a “collaborative roadmap toward regularization.” This would involve:
Extending the Deadline
Giving traders and the city council time to identify and prepare actual spaces.
Infrastructure Investment
Building the markets before enforcing the move.
Dialogue
Direct engagement between the Ministry and the People’s Parliament to ensure the transition doesn’t result in a humanitarian crisis.
As the September 9 deadline looms, the streets of Harare remain tense. The Ministry’s desire for a clean, orderly capital is a vision shared by many, including the traders themselves. However, as the petition from “We the People” vividly illustrates, a city is more than its aesthetics—it is its people.
If Minister Garwe heeds the call for collaboration, this moment could mark the beginning of a true formalization of Zimbabwe’s economy. If not, the “Impossible Mandate” may result in a fractured city where the quest for order leads only to further hardship.
About Author
